APPLICATION OF THE TENAX TECHNIQUE TO ASSESS BIOACCESSIBILITY OF SEDIMENT-ASSOCIATED POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS

Author

Federico Leonardo Sinche Chele, Southern Illinois University CarbondaleFollow

Date of Award

5-1-2018

Degree Name

Doctor of Philosophy

Department

Zoology

First Advisor

Lydy, Michael

Abstract

Sediments can act as both reservoir and source of legacy organic contaminants such as polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). Due to their chemical stability and ubiquity, these contaminants remain as model class of compounds in the field of sediment contamination. Whole sediment and organism concentrations have been often used as exposure metrics for ecological risk assessments. However, whole sediment concentrations often overestimate the potential for exposure to contaminants; while organism concentrations based on bioassay provide a better estimate of exposure, bioassays can also be labor intense, time consuming and expensive. Alternatively, accessiblity-based techniques such as Tenax extractions have been gaining ground, in the last few decades, as a rapid, reliable, and cost-effective approach to estimate exposure to organic contaminants from sediments. Tenax extractions measure the bioaccessible fraction of the contaminant that desorbes from sediment. Despite the simplicity, accuracy and robustness of the Tenax technique to estimate bioaccessibility of organic contaminants, there are still some remaining questions regarding the methodological standardization, and the applicability of the technique in sediments containing diverse carbonaceous sorbents associated adsorption/desorption of the contaminant. Therefore, the chapters of this dissertation were designed to address these questions. To this end, PCBs were chosen as a model compound class to represent a wide range of physicochemical properties of persistent organic contaminants, and because these compounds remain a worldwide legacy contamination problem. The dissertation goals were to: determine the best operational conditions for Tenax technique (Chapter 2); monitor the changes in bioaccessibility of field-collected sediments with different holding time conditions (Chapter 3); examine the effects of the type and quantity of organic carbon on bioaccessibility (Chapter 4); and evaluate the applicability of the Tenax technique to assess remediation success in contaminated marine sediments (Chapter 5). To address the methodological standardization of the Tenax technique, the operational parameters of solvent extract volume, Tenax sorption rate from water, and Tenax:OC (Tenax:Organic Carbon) ratios were investigated in Chapter 2. The highest efficiency of extraction of sorbed PCBs from Tenax resulted from using a 10 mL per each solvent wash during Tenax extraction procedure. For the Tenax sorption, it was found that 0.01 g of Tenax cleared PCB in 40 mL of water in 30 min, thus it would clear the water 48 times in 24 h. When this is extrapolated to the 0.5 of Tenax, typical amount used, it was found that the amount should clear the typical volume of water used on Tenax extraction about 2400 times. This represents unequivocal evidence that the Tenax resin would remove PCBs dissolved in the liquid phase (e.g., overlying or interstitial water) present in the sediment sample and be limited only by compound desorption and not by the Tenax sorption capacity. The results examining the impact of the relationship between the amount of Tenax required and the amount of organic carbon in the sediment extraction indicated that a minimum of 5:1 Tenax:OC ratio be used to conduct Tenax extractions. This will reduce (eliminate) the possibility of re-adsorption by the native OC in the sediment in competition with the Tenax. After ascertaining the best operational conditions for Tenax extractions, two additional methodological uncertainties, the effect of storage time after collection and the preservation method associated with the handling of collected sediment samples were investigated in Chapter 3. The effect of holding time and the preservation method on PCB concentrations from field-collected sediments was examined for a period of 196 d. All samples were held at 4 ºC in the dark and several holding times were chosen. The parameters to track the changes in PCB concentration in two sediments used three exposure metrics: exhaustive solvent extraction, tissue concentrations and Tenax extractions (Chapter 3). The results showed that the total exhaustive concentrations representing the whole sediment concentrations did not significantly change (ANOVA, p> 0.05) in either sediment over the course of 196 d. Similar results were also found for the total Tenax concentrations that represented the bioaccessible sediment concentrations, and for the total organism tissue concentrations representing exposure. The likely equilibrium of PCB in the sediment, their chemical stability of PCB and slow degradation can be underlined as the main factors leading to these results. The long time that legacy contaminants such as PCBs have been in contact with contaminated sites (e.g., Superfund sites) might have contributed to an equilibrium to be reached between the sediment particles and PCB molecules. The significance of this chapter is that sediments collected from PCB-contaminated sites can be stored longer than the 14 d as recommended by current standard protocols without disturbing the measures of bioavailability. The role of organic carbon composition within sediment on contaminant sorption was also investigated to ascertain the effects of type and quantity of OC from different origins on the bioaccessibility of PCBs in contaminated sediments (Chapter 4). Changes in PCB bioaccessibility in sediments amended at either 3 or 6% by dry weight with black carbon (BC), humic acid (HA) or sawdust (SD), showed that the lowest and highest PCB bioaccessibilities were observed in the BC and SD amendments, respectively. Specifically, the total amount of PCBs desorbed ranges from 3 to 27% for BC amendments, 12 to 55% for HA amendments and 16 to 80% for SD amendments. The results showed the influence of OC quantity on bioaccessibility having a much slower desorption of PCBs in 6% amendments compared to 3% amendments, and this finding was most evident in HA and BC amendments. The results also showed that the Tenax technique can be applied to tract the variation in type of carbon and quantity of OC in contaminated sediment to estimate exposure. Finally, the applicability of the Tenax technique as tool to assess the remediation success of PCB-contaminated marine sediments upon AC amendment at either 4.3 or 0.026% AC by dw was examined in Chapter 5. The results showed that bioaccessibility of PCBs was greatly reduced in sediment amended at the higher AC dose (4.3%); while, reduction was also observed even in the sediment amended at 0.026% AC. Furthermore, the results revealed that Tenax concentrations reflected the PCB reduction among AC amended sediments in the same direction as the PCB reduction in the organism bioaccumulation. Overall, this dissertation provides further evidence that the Tenax technique is a rapid, reliable, and cost-effective tool for estimating exposure to recalcitrant organic contaminants such as PCBs from contaminated sites. The applicability of the technique to estimate bioaccessible compound from both freshwater and marine aquatic sediments underline the robustness of the technique to widen its use among risk ecological assessor and researchers.