Inauthenticity, Delusion, and Victimization: Interrogating Affective Rhetoric Targeting Trans* Youth
Abstract
In this essay, I interrogate Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s KP-0401, a 2022 legal opinion letter that frames gender affirming healthcare as dangerous, sterilizing, and therefore, child abuse. Within this framing, trans* youth are presented as both delusional and deviant, written off as victims of abuse and social contagion. In analyzing KP-0401 through a critical perspective of affect and performativity, I demonstrate how particular affects have gained power through their circulation to reify feelings and performances of cisheteronormativity, often through establishing the trans* body as a source of negative affect, like fear or repulsion, and trans* youth as infantile and incompetent. By contrast, I argue that KP-0401 exemplifies how anti-trans* rhetoric operates within a positive affective orientation of love and parental protection that understands cisheteronormativity as extraideological—objective, natural, and logical to the point of being “beyond” ideological boundaries—and transphobia, by extension, as a similarly objective form of common sense. I conclude by reflecting on how KP-0401 served as a predecessor to virulent anti-trans* affects and legislation in 2023 as well as the powerful potentiality of trans* youth.
Recommended Citation
Bishop, Ben
(2023)
"Inauthenticity, Delusion, and Victimization: Interrogating Affective Rhetoric Targeting Trans* Youth,"
Kaleidoscope: A Graduate Journal of Qualitative Communication Research: Vol. 21, Article 11.
Available at:
https://opensiuc.lib.siu.edu/kaleidoscope/vol21/iss1/11